One of the most powerful ways to help students grow as musicians is to give them ownership of the music-making process. In a traditional concert band setting, this can be difficult. Much of the repertoire comes fully notated, with expressive markings, tempo, and dynamics already decided by the composer or arranger. While this ensures consistency in performance, it leaves little room for students to make interpretive decisions, develop their own musical voice, or explore the expressiveness within music.
Small ensemble experiences provide a natural way to bridge this gap. Without a conductor guiding every gesture, students must take responsibility for shaping the music together. It forces them to listen more carefully, communicate more clearly, and collaborate intentionally. Chamber music becomes not just a supplement to large ensemble rehearsals, but a laboratory for student growth.
Even with limited rehearsal space, small ensemble skills can be embedded into the large ensemble setting. Over time, students learn to analyze, interpret, and reflect on musical choices in ways that benefit the entire ensemble. One strategy I use is handing out a short piece, a quartet, trio, or duet, with minimal expressive markings.
When selecting pieces, I look for:
- Connections to current fundamental skills
- Appropriate melodic and rhythmic ideas
- Independent lines that interlock effectively
- Interpretive flexibility due to minimal markings
Public domain scores or adapted excerpts from larger works can work well. A great place to start is the Garner Ensemble Project published here on Band Director Talk Shop. Without prescribed tempo, dynamics, or articulation, students must ask and answer the musical questions themselves:
- How fast should we go?
- Where should we breathe?
- Should this line be accented or legato?
- How loud should this section be?
This shift, placing responsibility for interpretation in the students’ hands, changes how they think about music. They begin to explore not just what is written, but how the music can come to life.
Bringing Small Ensemble Skills into the Large Ensemble
1. Score Study
I start with students examining the music together as a class, identifying key and time signatures, rhythms, and overall structure. As they progress, they start to notice how individual lines interlock and interact, promoting both score literacy and ensemble awareness. This shared understanding lays the foundation for a cohesive and interpretive performance.
2. Learning the Lines
Next, we perform each line in unison before combining into pairs, trios, and eventually all layers together. This ensures that every student internalizes the material, even if it is not their assigned part. Performing each line in this way helps students develop a sense of timing, rhythm, and melodic interaction that will guide them as they bring all parts together.
3. Adding Style and Expression
As a class, we collaboratively explore phrasing, articulation, balance, and dynamics. Discussions may begin with teacher prompts but quickly become student-led, encouraging experimentation and multiple approaches. This process helps students gain confidence in making interpretive decisions and fosters a deeper connection to the music.
4. Assigning or Choosing Parts
I will then assign or let students select parts, listening to ensure there is balance across the ensemble. This step reinforces the significance of each part while encouraging discussion about balance and interpretation. It also encourages students to consider how their individual contributions fit within the overall sound.
5. Perform, Listen, Reflect
Lastly, I select small groups to perform for their peers. Those not playing listen for phrasing, articulation, blend, or dynamic contrast. Reflection and feedback cycles help students sharpen their listening skills, evaluate musical choices, and refine their interpretations. This process encourages active engagement and thoughtful collaboration in every rehearsal.
Implementation Tips
- Start with simple decision-making choices and gradually increase complexity.
- Integrate small ensemble sessions regularly, or as focused warm-ups, to reinforce skills efficiently.
- Encourage experimentation and discussion; mistakes become learning opportunities.
The Noticeable Difference
When students shape music rather than merely reproduce it, I have found their relationship to the ensemble transforms. I see them become more confident, independent, and invested in the rehearsal process.
Through this work, students learn to:
- Listen actively and responsively
- Make intentional musical decisions
- Collaborate in shaping interpretations
- Take ownership of their sound and contribution
These habits carry straight into the whole ensemble. Students start anticipating phrasing, balancing their parts naturally, and engaging with the music on a deeper level. The conductor is no longer the only decision-maker; the ensemble shares the responsibility for expression. The result is a rehearsal environment where students are proactive musicians, not passive participants.
Small ensemble work isn’t a side activity; it’s a mindset that can change the way your band plays and learns. It turns students into listeners, interpreters, collaborators, and thinkers. By practicing active listening, making musical decisions, and reflecting together, they move beyond simply playing the notes. They become musicians who play with meaning and confidence, discovering what it feels like to be both the artist and the architect of their own performance.
Dr. Dave McGarry is a dedicated music educator with 14 years of experience teaching band in Manitoba and British Columbia, Canada. He earned his PhD in Music Education from Liberty University, focusing his research on fostering critical thinking in music classrooms. Passionate about student-centered learning, he emphasizes small ensemble work and active listening to develop well-rounded, thoughtful musicians.
The Garner Ensemble Project mentioned above contains 60+ ensembles – a variety of duets/duettino alternators/trios & quartets from beginner level to advanced. You can download them instantly at no charge here:
Access The Garner Ensemble Project Set 1 here
Access The Garner Ensemble Project Set 2 here
Leave a Reply
You must be logged in to post a comment.